Gifts

Mama Mary's Bakery Famous Sugar Cookies with Butter Icing

Mama Mary's Bakery Famous Sugar Cookies with Butter Icing

Macy's $22.99 Go to Macy's First seen in May 2021

Description

Mama Mary's most famous recipe. These cookies are the reason her legacy continues today and this it is not just a sugar cookie, but it is a little slice of heaven. We wish we could put into words how delicious they are, but you will just have to try them yourself to find out.

You may also like

Ghirardelli Dark and Caramel Sea Salt Chocolate Squares Bag from Macy's

Quick View

Ghirardelli Nature's
Ghirardelli Dark and Caramel Sea Salt Chocolate Squares Bag

from Macy's

Fiesta Spice Blend Collection Gift Set from Macy's

Quick View

Alchemy Spice
Fiesta Spice Blend Collection Gift Set

from Macy's

6' Autumn Maple Leaf and Berry Fall Garland from Macy's

Quick View

Nearly Natural
6' Autumn Maple Leaf and Berry Fall Garland

from Macy's

Thank You Caramel Apple Gift Tray from Macy's

Quick View

Mrs. Prindables
Thank You Caramel Apple Gift Tray

from Macy's

Mini Milk Chocolate Bar Christmas Advent Calendar from Macy's

Quick View

House Of Dorchester
Mini Milk Chocolate Bar Christmas Advent Calendar

from Macy's

Mary Macleod's Variety Signature Cookie Tin Shortbread Cookies Gift from Macy's

Quick View

Mary Macleod's Shortbread
Mary Macleod's Variety Signature Cookie Tin Shortbread Cookies Gift

from Macy's

Assorted Cinnamon Roasted Nuts Gift Tin from Macy's

Quick View

Old World Style Almonds
Assorted Cinnamon Roasted Nuts Gift Tin

from Macy's

The Mandalorian Grogu Valentine's Day Heart Tin and Candy Dispenser Bundle from Macy's

Quick View

Star Wars
The Mandalorian Grogu Valentine's Day Heart Tin and Candy Dispenser Bundle

from Macy's

A Smile Today Gift Box from Macy's

Quick View

GBDS
A Smile Today Gift Box

from Macy's

Chocolatier 5-Pc. Pumpkin Spice Chocolate Truffle Flight from Macy's

Quick View

Godiva
Chocolatier 5-Pc. Pumpkin Spice Chocolate Truffle Flight

from Macy's

Original Newman from Macy's

Quick View

Newman's Own Organics
Original Newman

from Macy's

105 pcs Bridal Shower Candy Hershey's Chocolate Mix from Macy's

Quick View

Just Candy
105 pcs Bridal Shower Candy Hershey's Chocolate Mix

from Macy's

Assorted Gourmet Italian Cookies Red Heart Tin from Macy's

Quick View

Cookies Con Amore
Assorted Gourmet Italian Cookies Red Heart Tin

from Macy's

Gourmet, Mini Boba Party Set, Makes 16 Tasting Portions Of Bubble Tea from Macy's

Quick View

Thoughtfully
Gourmet, Mini Boba Party Set, Makes 16 Tasting Portions Of Bubble Tea

from Macy's

White and Black Truffle Oil Gift Selection from Macy's

Quick View

Trufflehunter
White and Black Truffle Oil Gift Selection

from Macy's

230 pcs Valentine's Day Gift Tin with Hershey's Holiday Chocolate Candy Mix from Macy's

Quick View

Just Candy
230 pcs Valentine's Day Gift Tin with Hershey's Holiday Chocolate Candy Mix

from Macy's

Happy Holidays Wooden Gift Basket from Macy's

Quick View

Alder Creek Gift Baskets
Happy Holidays Wooden Gift Basket

from Macy's

41 Pcs Black Candy Party Favors Hershey's Miniatures Chocolate from Macy's

Quick View

Just Candy
41 Pcs Black Candy Party Favors Hershey's Miniatures Chocolate

from Macy's

100ct Fire Truck Birthday Candy Party Favors Hershey's Kisses Milk Chocolate (100 Candies + 1 Sheet Stickers) Candy Included from Macy's

Quick View

Just Candy
100ct Fire Truck Birthday Candy Party Favors Hershey's Kisses Milk Chocolate (100 Candies + 1 Sheet Stickers) Candy Included

from Macy's

14lbs+ Deluxe Orange Candy Buffet from Macy's

Quick View

Just Candy
14lbs+ Deluxe Orange Candy Buffet

from Macy's

Holiday White Chocolate Peppermint Cookies from Macy's

Quick View

Bissinger's Handcrafted Chocolate
Holiday White Chocolate Peppermint Cookies

from Macy's

Mini Snack Packs from Macy's

Quick View

Junior Mints
Mini Snack Packs

from Macy's

84ct Chinese New Year Candy Chocolate Coins Party Favors from Macy's

Quick View

Just Candy
84ct Chinese New Year Candy Chocolate Coins Party Favors

from Macy's

14lbs+ Deluxe Gold Candy Buffet from Macy's

Quick View

Just Candy
14lbs+ Deluxe Gold Candy Buffet

from Macy's

No Place Like Home Housewarming Gift Box- housewarming gift baskets from Macy's

Quick View

GBDS
No Place Like Home Housewarming Gift Box- housewarming gift baskets

from Macy's

Classic Cinnamon Rolls from Macy's

Quick View

Wolferman's
Classic Cinnamon Rolls

from Macy's

Lindt Holiday Delights from Macy's

Quick View

Alder Creek Gift Baskets
Lindt Holiday Delights

from Macy's

I Woof You Plush Valentine With chocolates gift set from Macy's

Quick View

GBDS
I Woof You Plush Valentine With chocolates gift set

from Macy's

123 Pcs Engagement Party Candy Party Favors Hershey's Miniatures Chocolate from Macy's

Quick View

Just Candy
123 Pcs Engagement Party Candy Party Favors Hershey's Miniatures Chocolate

from Macy's

Trolls Finders Keepers Milk Chocolate Eggs with Troll Collectors Case from Macy's

Quick View

Finders Keepers
Trolls Finders Keepers Milk Chocolate Eggs with Troll Collectors Case

from Macy's

Leaky Gut Revive Max 30 Servings from Macy's

Quick View

Amy Myers Md
Leaky Gut Revive Max 30 Servings

from Macy's

41 Pcs Halloween Candy Party Favors Hershey's Miniatures Chocolate from Macy's

Quick View

Just Candy
41 Pcs Halloween Candy Party Favors Hershey's Miniatures Chocolate

from Macy's

82 Pcs Christmas Candy Party Favors Hershey's Miniatures Chocolate from Macy's

Quick View

Just Candy
82 Pcs Christmas Candy Party Favors Hershey's Miniatures Chocolate

from Macy's

Happy Fall Y'All Tower Gift Set from Macy's

Quick View

Alder Creek Gift Baskets
Happy Fall Y'All Tower Gift Set

from Macy's

Autumn Classic Box of Chocolates from Macy's

Quick View

Bissinger's Handcrafted Chocolate
Autumn Classic Box of Chocolates

from Macy's

Dip Mix with a Bamboo Spoon from Macy's

Quick View

Sauce Goddess
Dip Mix with a Bamboo Spoon

from Macy's

3 Pack Variety Seasonings Gift Set from Macy's

Quick View

Sandwich Goat Seasonings
3 Pack Variety Seasonings Gift Set

from Macy's

24ct 70th Birthday Candy Party Favors Wrapped Hershey's Chocolate Bars by from Macy's

Quick View

Just Candy
24ct 70th Birthday Candy Party Favors Wrapped Hershey's Chocolate Bars by

from Macy's

2021 Limited Edition Collectors Set from Macy's

Quick View

Star Wars
2021 Limited Edition Collectors Set

from Macy's

Signature Chocolate Truffle Gift Box from Macy's

Quick View

Godiva
Signature Chocolate Truffle Gift Box

from Macy's

loading

Discover more

We may earn a commission when you use our links to visit a store and make a purchase. We use cookies to enhance your experience with us. Read more. OK